FCP 7 Reads Progressive Video as Interlaced. Why?

Posted by JBsnapshots 
FCP 7 Reads Progressive Video as Interlaced. Why?
February 13, 2013 02:05PM
Using FCP 7 on OSX 10.7.5

Overview: 1080p video from Canon Rebel processed through MpegStreamclip (interlace box deselected) at ProRess 422. When dropped into FCP item properties reads video field dominance as Upper Odd.

Tests: Dropped same video directly into Compressor which reads media as Progressive, field dominance none. Reinstalled FCP 7 & MpegStreamclip repeating process with same results. Treated sample clip three ways in Mpeg Streamclip: (1 uncheck interlaced box (2. only checking deinterlace box (3 checking interlaced and deinterlace box.

All three video clips read as Interlaced (UPPER ODD) when separately loaded in old and new FCP project.

For unknown reasons my copy of FCP 7 is reading progressive footage from Canon's Rebel treated with MpegStreamclip as interlaced video causing issues in DVD burn quality.

Please advise as all common steps have been taken to amend the issue.
Re: FCP 7 Reads Progressive Video as Interlaced. Why?
February 13, 2013 06:01PM
MPEG Streamclip might be making the progressive file interlaced. Or it might correctly leave it progressive and then FCP misinterprets it as interlaced. Video software is full of field handling bugs.
It's a trivial error in the header of the file. No frames have been riven or new fields created, yet. The easiest fix is use QT Edit to edit the troublesome QuickTime file header. Change 'interlaced' to 'progressive' and change the field order to 'unknown'.
What seems an even easier fix, to change the FCP sequence settings to progressive, is a big mistake. The file will become progressive but half the fields will be discarded in the process.

Dennis Couzin
Berlin, Germany
Re: FCP 7 Reads Progressive Video as Interlaced. Why?
February 14, 2013 07:47AM
Ingest it using Log and Transfer.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login

 


Google
  Web lafcpug.org

Web Hosting by HermosawaveHermosawave Internet


Recycle computers and electronics